Top Bar
Musique Machine Logo Home ButtonReviews ButtonArticles ButtonBand Specials ButtonAbout Us Button
SearchGo Down
Search for  
With search mode in section(s)
And sort the results by
show articles written by  
 Review archive:  # a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z

Paul Norbury - Smiling Men With Bad Reputations: The Story of the [Grosvenor House Publishing Limited - 2016]

Smiling Men With Bad Reputations is an attempt to be a give a  balanced & even- handed listeners guide to the work of one of the most creative bands of the 1960 ’s, and their two main songwriters.  I’ve been a  fan of The Incredible String Band, for around ten plus years now, and heard all of their output, but never really ventured very far into either Williamson's or Heron’s work- so when I saw this book was out it seemed a very appealing proposition.

The book is 230-page A5 sized paperback- utilizing mainly black & white text layout, with each release cover reproduced in color. With the chapters broken up into years- so it runs between 1963 to 2006- covering all of the ISB releases(including live albums & comps), and of course all of Williamson & Heron's post ISB.

From the books outset & the introduction, it’s clear the book's author Paul Norbury, is long time,  highly-knowledgeable & devoted fan of both ISB & Williamson/ Heron solo work. And though-out, even in the ISB parts of the book, I gained new facts & some interesting insights on the history side of things, so I’m certainly grateful for those. So the history/ facts side of the book can’t be faulted.

The history/ fact side of the book is naturally interwoven with the main books main coverage i.e. the albums themselves.  And most of these write-ups/ critique focus into more towards the lyrical side of things, and less on the musical side of things. Sure I appreciate the importance of the lyrics, and with the ISB albums- it certainly made me look a new at some of my favorite tracks. The problem came when I moved into the latter part of the book, and the solo albums I’m not familiar with, and sadly this is where the book fell down for me- as I was looking for more sonic insights, instead of the mainly lyrical focus.

So, as a result, I came away from the book as a whole more than a little disappointed, and I’m sure if you’d never had heard any of the ISB albums- you’d be even more disappointed. The whole thing really needed to be more evenly balanced between musical & lyrical- so as it stands Smiling Men With Bad Reputations, is very much of a lopsided affair.

In conclusion, it’s always great to see new reissues & releases of ISB work on the market; but I’m afraid unless you're after a mix of facts & lyrical analyzing- you may also come away from this book feeling more than a little disappointed too.

Rating: 2 out of 5Rating: 2 out of 5Rating: 2 out of 5Rating: 2 out of 5Rating: 2 out of 5

Roger Batty
Latest Reviews

Paul Norbury - Smiling Men Wit...
Smiling Men With Bad Reputations is an attempt to be a give a  balanced & even- handed listeners guide to the work of one of the most creative bands...
290324   Piranha - Piranha(DVD)
280324   Typhoon Club - Typhoon Club(B...
270324   Jerzy Skolimowski Collection ...
260324   Latex Choker - Sealed
260324   Occlusion - 59: No Input Wall
260324   Nihil Impvlse - Anabasis
260324   Marta Forsberg - Sjunger För...
260324   The New Boy - The New Boy( Th...
250324   The Stargazer’s Assistant - ...
250324   Liza Lim - Annunciation Trip...
Latest Articles

The Music of Clay Ruby & Burial H...
Over the last couple of decades Wisconsin native, Clay Ruby has been creating some of the world’s finest dark electronic music under the Burial Hex mon...
280324   The Music of Clay Ruby & Buri...
290224   Sutcliffe No More - Normal Ev...
100124   Occlusion - The Operation Is...
181223   Best Of 2023 - Music, Sound &...
051223   Powerhouse Films - Of Magic, ...
181023   IO - Of Sound, Of Art, Of Exp...
210923   Lucky Cerruti - Of Not so Fri...
290823   The Residents - The Trouble W...
110723   Yotzeret Sheydim Interview - ...
250523   TenHornedBeast - Into The Dee...
Go Up
(c) Musique Machine 2001 -2023. Twenty two years of true independence!! Mail Us at questions=at=musiquemachine=dot=comBottom